|
Glycerol
Glycerol-Hyperhydration
or Hype?
Over
the past few years glycerol - a colorless, syrupy
liquid - has been added to the ever-growing list
of sports supplements that tout increased performance.
Fluid balance in the body is well maintained when
you are sitting around on your couch.
But
when you begin to exercise, water loss is increased
dramatically. Two to three liters can be lost
in an hour, but rehydration is usually less than
500 ml per hour during competition.(1,2)
Glycerol's claim to fame is that is appears to
be capable of creating an increased state of hydration
in the human body. It helps your body retain water.
This is of great benefit to any athlete, as dehydration
of as little as 1% of body weight can decrease
"work capacity."
When we examine the most recent research on glycerol's
role in increased hydration, we must consider
if the positive, athletic benefits hold water
themselves.
Out of 10 studies we reviewed at the Colgan Institute,
the first four all indicated that urine flow rates
and/or urine volumes were decreased. This appears
good for glycerol use in athletic endeavors. But
in three of the tests, the subjects did not exercise
and in the fourth, the decrease in urine volume
was measured prior to exercise.(3-6) You can't
use these results to justify adding glycerol to
your marathon program.
In the next four studies, the test subjects used
treadmills or cycles at anywhere from 50% maximum
oxygen intake (VO2) to exhaustion, testing a glycerol
solution versus rehydration with either water
or carbohydrate solution. (7-10) All the results
showed no added benefit of hydrating with glycerol.
The ninth study reported an ergogenic effect from
glycerol hydration in a two study design.(11)
In the first stage, 11 subjects were given either
a 20% glycerol solution or a placebo, one hour
before cycling at 60% of maximum workload. No
extra water was given and although there was no
change in rectal temperatures or sweat rates between
the two groups, there was an increase in endurance
and a reduction in heart rate in the glycerol
group.
In the second stage of the study, a 5% dextrose
solution was given every 20 minutes, and a slight
increase in endurance over the control group was
once again recorded in the test subjects using
glycerol. The last study showed no cardiovascular
benefits or thermoregulatory effects, though fluid
retention was indicated.(12)
What are we to make of these contradictory results?
In practical terms, it appears that proper hydration
prior to, and during exercise, with either carbohydrate
solution or just plain water, will protect you
just as well as trying to hydrate yourself with
glycerol supplement.
Until more conclusive research can show consistent,
positive results of the use of glycerol, it appears
you should keep your money in your pocket. Any
possible benefit that glycerol will enhance your
athletic prowess is, at best, short lived, and
completely unneccessary if you replenish yourself
with water frequently. If you decide to try glycerol
anyway, note that although it is deemed safe at
dosages of 1 g/kg of body weight, some studies
have indicated you may feel nausea and suffer
from vomiting, bloating or lightheadedness.(5,8,9)
These are not exactly the feelings most folk would
look forward to during the heat of battle.
For rehydrartion, we recommend nothing stronger
than 7% carbohydrate solution. Carbohydrate drinks
that contain higher than 7% solution don't take
into account that digestion stops during exercise.
As the demand for oxygen by the muscles increases,
blood flow is directed towards the extremities,
away from the stomach. Water is readily absorbed
by the body but most sports drinks remain in the
stomach, sloshing around and causing nausea.
Rehydrate continuously while exercising, running
or playing your favourite sport. Colgan Institute
CRUX is an ideal carbohydrate powder that was
originally developed for Mt. Everest expeditions,
and can be added to water at different concentrations.
References
1.
Noakes TD. Fluid replacement during exercise.
Exer Sports Sci Rev, 1993;21:297-300.
2. Noakes TD, et al. The importance of volume
in regulating gastric emptying. Med
Sci Sports Exer, 1991;23:307-313
3. Freund BJ, et al. Glycerol hyperhydration:
hormonal, renal, and vascular fluid responses.
J Appl Physiol, 1995;79:2069-2077
4. Riedesel ML, it al. Hyperhydration with glycerol
solutions. J appl Physiol, 1987;63:2262-2077
5. Koenigsberg PS; et al. Sustained hyperhydration
with glycerol ingestion. Life Sci, 1995;57:645-653
6. Lyons TP, et al. Effects of glycerol induced
hyperhydration prior to exercise in the heat on
sweating and core temperature. Med Sci Sports
Exer, 1990;22:447-483.
Find
more information at www.colganchronicles.com
|